Propane tank lease vs. buy

Check tank ownership before closing and compare the same three years of fuel, deliveries, fees, and equipment costs.

Propane tank closing checklist

Confirm the tank and current contract before you plan your first delivery.

Tank ownership

Choose what you know to see the right first step.

Before closing

Check off each item as you go.

Maine Department of Energy Resources propane consumer guide (PDF)

Compare propane tank quotes

Exclude any refundable deposit from the upfront price and enter it on its own line. Use 0 for a rate covered elsewhere in the quote.

How we compare quotes

Use the same three years for both quotes

Enter whole gallons and deliveries per year. The comparison applies those amounts for three years at the rates you enter.

Start with the quote

Use a one-time base price. Leave any unpriced charge blank.

Quote A

Quote B

Tank purchase

What does ownership cost, and who provides proof of ownership?

Quote A
Quote B

Tank installation and setup

Are delivery of the tank, setup, connection, and initial inspection included?

Quote A
Quote B

Switch or account transfer fee

Ask which one-time service, inspection, or account transfer fees apply.

Quote A
Quote B

Tank rent

Enter the annual total for the tank lease or rental fees.

USD per year
Quote A
Quote B

Propane fuel rate

Enter the delivered fuel rate per gallon for your usage tier.

USD per gallon
Quote A
Quote B

Delivery charge

Enter the fee per delivery and confirm when the supplier applies it.

USD per delivery
Quote A
Quote B

Recurring service or inspection

Enter the annual service charges and record what they cover.

USD per year
Quote A
Quote B

Tank pickup, return or pump-out

Enter applicable one-time exit fees for the three-year scenario.

Quote A
Quote B

Refundable deposit

Confirm the amount, conditions for refund, and any nonrefundable fees separately.

Separate from the total
Quote A
Quote B

Scope notes (optional)

Capture scope differences, recurring charges, and billing frequency.

Your entries stay in this browser tab.

What to check

Propane tank lease vs. buy cost

Propane tank lease vs. buy cost depends on your usage, the fuel price per gallon, ownership, and written fees. Compare the same annual gallons and delivery count. Use your supplier’s current written rates and any known switching or removal charge.

Confirm the contract and the gallons

Use past bills to estimate annual use. Ask about delivery fees, minimum orders, service and price changes, notice periods, and how the agreement treats fuel remaining in the tank.

Check charges tied to starting or ending service

The Maine Department of Energy Resources guide discusses buying a tank, switching suppliers, and possible fees. AmeriGas lists example company charges with conditions. Get a written schedule for your location, tank and contract.

Record the conditions of a refundable deposit

Record refundable security deposits separately. Ask which payments are nonrefundable and put those into the appropriate charge line.

Tank arrangement options

Buy and own
Get the tank and installation price, inspection terms, and what maintenance you will pay for.
Lease the tank
Ask about rental charges, minimum usage, fuel pricing, and what it costs to end the agreement.
Keep tank, switch supplier
Confirm tank ownership and whether the new supplier will deliver after inspection.